When Orlando was a small town, a group of mainly Midwestern people of German heritage were attracted here and gathered together with Pastor George Trapp to form Trinity Evangelical Lutheran Church in 1919. By 1921 they had built a small sanctuary on Hughey Street, where the Orlando Police Department is now headquartered, but that building was outgrown and sold in a very short time. After renting space for worship for several years, Trinity’s current sanctuary was built in late 1926, and the congregation began worshiping here in 1927.
Talk about timing! The great Florida Boom turned into the great Florida Bust in the late ‘20s, followed by the Great Depression, and many of Trinity’s members moved back to the Midwest. Those who remained struggled mightily to preserve their fellowship and sanctuary. By God’s grace Trinity weathered that storm, but remained a small group until the post-World War II expansion of Orlando brought many Lutherans to live and work here.
After the death of Pastor Trapp in 1946, Pastor Albert Besalski arrived and served during Trinity’s explosive growth during the ‘50s and early ‘60s. As Orlando grew, so did Trinity. Acquiring land to the west of the sanctuary in the late ‘40s, our school began in 1953 with Kindergarten and first grade, growing to sixth grade before 1960, and to eighth grade in the early ‘70s. With the acquisition of the little red house to the north of the sanctuary came expansion in the other direction, our Child Development Center serving younger children starting in 1983.
When Pastor Besalski accepted a call to serve a church in Alabama in 1964, Pastor James Kunze, his assistant and a son of the congregation, served as senior pastor. A number of assistant and associate pastors, and a few vicars, served here during Pastor Besalski and Pastor Kunze’s tenures, including Pastors Ed Trinklein, Gerald Seaman, Milan Weerts, and Lloyd Goetz.
In 1989 Pastor Ronald Fink arrived, serving here until 1999. He was assisted by Pastor Kunze until his death from cancer in 1994, followed by associate pastors Mark Joeckel and Scott Heitshusen.
When Pastor Fink retired, Trinity was served during a three-year vacancy by Pastor Bill Reinhardt. Associate Pastor Jon van Sliedrecht served here 2004-2007.
Pastor Jeff Moore served Trinity as Senior Pastor from 2003 through December, 2014. Pastor Billy Brath served at Trinity from 2009 through June 2015 as Trinity’s Urban Missionary and Associate Pastor.
Rev. Thomas R. Zehnder served as Trinity’s Interim Senior Pastor from January through May of 2015. Rev. Jim Martin was called to serve as Trinity’s Interim Senior Pastor from June 2015 to July 2016 and in November of 2016 Rev. Thomas R. Zehnder returned to Trinity as Interim Senior Pastor while Trintiy continues its Senior Pastor call process, followed by Rev. Larry Schaefer serving as Trinity’s vacancy pastor as the call process continues.
Today Trinity’s School ministry cares for and educates nearly 400 children from six weeks old through eighth grade. Our worshiping congregation averages about 300 people per weekend, with many opportunities for Christian service in reaching out to Orlando and the world. With 97 years of history behind us, Trinity is excited to begin a second century of sharing Jesus with those around us.